Draft dilemma: the five hole

I’ve maintained all winter long that the top four picks in a standard draft are going to be essentially the same in every draft: A-Rod, Pujols, Vladdy and Teixeira. I’ve also been adamant that the next 10-15 picks, starting at #5, are going to be a free-for-all and can go in virtually any order, making it better from a value standpoint to be closer to the end of the draft than the top. Well, guess what position I have in the Fantasy 411 listener league draft tomorrow night? Right, number five.

I’ve run through various scenarios in my head and right now I’m down to three players who I think are the top options with the pick: Carl Crawford, Derrek Lee and Manny Ramirez. There are arguments to be made for a few others, but these seem to be the leading candidates in most drafts… so let’s examine each one on his merits:

Carl Crawford

  • Pros: A top-five stolen base threat who also adds a good amount of power, unlike "specialists" like Podsednik. He’s only 25 and his power has increased each year, too, making an 18-20 homer season a real possibility. The D’Rays lineup should be stronger this year, so it’s not unreasonable that he could drive in 75 or more runs again and score over 100.
  • Cons: It’s hard to envision him maintaining his .290+ average with a 3-to-1 strikeout-to-walk rate and fewer than 30 walks every year. His plate discipline has not improved, in fact it declined last year, making a dip in average likely. And reports on the bone bruise in his hand range from, "it’s no big deal" to "it’s a very big deal." Medhead friend Will Carroll of Baseball Prospectus wonders if the lingering bruise indicates a hairline fracture, although he says both are essentially treatable the same way and with the same recovery timeline.

Derrek Lee

  • Pros: He’s averaged 16 steals over the past four seasons, so he’s more likely to provide value in that category than Pujols or Bay, whose steals spiked unexpectedly last season. He’s always had good plate discipline, so he should maintain a .300 average or so, although I’m not expecting anything near .335 again. At his size and age, it’s not unreasonable to think he’ll maintain some of the power spike and sit in the 35-40 homer range for a few years. And, the Cubs lineup is much better this year with Pierre setting the table, so he’ll drive in more than 107 runs this time around.
  • Cons: Three big ones. First, the bruised shoulder. It’s said to be something he can play through, but as with Crawford, any injury risk becomes magnified when it’s a first round pick. Second, we know last year was a career year, but how much of the growth can he maintain? If he dips 10%, he’s the Vladimir Guerrero of 1st baseman. If he drops back down to his 2003-2004 levels, he’ll be a good 4th rounder, not 5th overall. And third, first base is incredibly deep this year… do I need to spend this early a pick on one when I can get Thome or Huff or Morneau or several other decent options 6-8 or more rounds later?

Manny Ramirez

  • Pros: A clockwork orange of offensive production, averaging .315 with 40 HR, 122 RBIs and 103 runs in his five years with the Red Sox; his slow start last year dragged down what was actually another elite year. As long as he hits among Crisp, Loretta, Ortiz, Varitek and the rest, he should easily match those numbers again this year. Plus, I like to have a big outfield, and it’s not terribly deep this year in terms of top-end options.
  • Cons: He’ll be 34 this year and has to slow down at some point. He’s a headcase, and a trade from Boston, or even rumors of it, could throw off his production. He does not steal at all, and speed is always at a premium.

In some respects, who I pick at #5 isn’t really the issue… who I get (or think I can get) with my second and third round picks will ultimately influence my decision as much as anything else. If I think there’s going to be a run on speed throughout the early rounds, Crawford is the pick. If I decide to take a more balanced approach, Lee is the choice. And if I want to gamble on getting speed later with specialists like Pods, Manny is the best option. So right now I’m running multiple mock-draft scenarios in my head, trying to figure out who might be available for me with those next two picks. I probably won’t decide until it’s time to click the button around 10:04 p.m. ET tomorrow night…

Of course, I could go for David Wright or Bobby Abreu or Jason Bay or Miguel Cabrera or Johan Santana or David Ortiz…



I just had a draft with some friends and got the #6 pick. After Manny was taken at 5, I took Ortiz. I was disappointed that I now have no speed though (after Ichiro, Sheff is my most speed), and that I was able to get Thome in round 10 (but is now on my bench cause my UTIL has Chavez and Wells). If you don’t take Crawford here, I’d say you have to get a speedster in the next two picks (Ichiro if he drops to you in 2, Figgins or Beltran in 2, or Rollins if he drop to 3). The safe choice would be to take Crawford and pick up Carlos Lee, Hafner, Berkman, A-Ram, or Sheff in a couple rounds, rather than hoping the couple speedsters are still there.
And now that you mention it, I may try to make a deal that involves Ortiz for Crawford (who went 12 in my draft).

Brad from Rockford

Heya Cory,

I know you don’t like to overpay for pitching, but wouldn’t Johan be a nice pick at #5 for you? Seems, with you’re style of pitch-or-ditch, having a solid anchor like Santana would compliment your team nicely. I took Johan with the #4 pick in one league, though admittedly I did alot of experimenting with that draft. I went much heavier with pitching then I did/do with with most leagues.

I think Crawford at #5 is too high, as you can probably get Beltran in the second round and he has more power potential.

Oh, here’s an idea…take Ted Lily at #5. I can’t think of better way to renew an old romance! Just think of the shock value! Plus, you’ll save Siano a T-Shirt, as nobody will get the 1st round right! hehe

May the Schwartz be with you!

JFT – JohnfromTexas

Santana at the 5 works for me.

Or you could go with George Mason!🙂

In my five hole position I actually went with Ortiz, who is much like Manny, I survived the speed scare by getting Bay in the 2nd, Rollins in the 3rd and Beltran in the 5th. I’m happy with that🙂


Bertil from Sweden

Reasons to move to Sweden:

* Blondes

* Socialized health care

* Beltran in the 5th

Thanks Bertil!


And don’t forget

* Olympic Gold in icehockey (and womens curling!)

Btw I doubt that I would be able to find enough people in Sweden for a 12 team league, this was a Yahoo league.



Bay at 20 and Beltran in the 5th? I want in that league.

I was hoping to get Bay at 19 in my league, but around the 15th pick, my brother kept telling people to not let him drop to me. Oh well, Ichiro ended up being my only speed (until I traded for Beltran).

Brad from Rockford

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: