April 2010
Pitch or Ditch for Saturday-Monday, May 1-3
SATURDAY
G.Gonzalez @ Eveland -the shine
is off Eveland, but I’ll try Gio against the strikeout-prone
Jays
F.Garcia @
Vazquez – I’ll give Javy one more chance
Harrison @ King
Felix
Davies @ Price
- mismatch of the night, which means the Royals will win
12-1
Dice-K @ Bergesen - good
matchup for Dice-K’s return
Kazmir @
Bonderman
Slowey @ Masterson -
Masterson melted down last time but I’ll give him a second
chance
Myers @
Hudson – nice matchup for
both against weak offenses
Bailey @
Lohse
Pelfrey @
Halladay – if Pelfrey passes
this test he’s officially graduated, at least for now!
E. Rogers @
Cain
Olsen @
Volstad
Gallardo @ Latos – Latos got
smashed last time and the Brewers can do some smashing
Haren @ Silva – can Silva
silence the powerful D-backs??
Duke @ Haeger
SUNDAY
Liriano @
Huff
Buehrle @
Hughes – sitting it out on Buehrle right now
Sheets @ Marcum
- sitting it out with Sheets, too
Beckett @
Millwood
Greinke @ W.
Davis
Weaver @ Verlander -
great matchup
Wilson @ Fister -
favorable matchup for both pitchers
Harang @
Carpenter – Harang isn’t out of the woods yet
Norris @ Lowe -
favorable matchups for the pitchers
Jackson @ Gorzelanny – E-Jax
will bounce back vs. weak Cubs
Chacin @ J.
Sanchez – Gustavo Chacin!? Really!??!?
Wolf @
Garland
Karstens @
Kuroda – I wouldn’t start Karstens, but deep and NL-only leaguers might gamble here based
on how bad the Dodgers are without Manny
Lannan @
Johnson
J.
Santana @
Moyer
MONDAY
Saunders @
Buchholz
Cecil @ Talbot – great
2-start week for Cecil
Guthrie @
Sabathia
Meche @ Peavy
- last chance for Peavy before the bench
Scherzer @ Baker
-
Baker running out of leash also
Harden @
Braden
J. Garcia @
Hamels
Maine @ Leake -
reasonable place to gamble on Maine
Mulvey @
Paulino
Jimenez @ Correia -
Correia pitching well, and at home
***Siano says:
Ditch on Lowe. I know it’s the Stros but he literally has one good start and
in that start he walked 7. Prey on the weak is fine so feel free to ignore but I
smell a trap.
Pitch on Gorz, risky because the D-backs are on all cylinders but I’m digging
him.
If
it was Gustavo I would have said PITCH!!!! I still wear his
cologne.
For Monday, I
think Peavy starts a turnaround a la Lester just not as good.
Pitch
Baker
is borderline DTM, luckily for him he’s had two really good starts this year. Pitch.
Big
test for Garcia, the angel on shoulder says ditch or more specifically put on
bench but the devil says leave the kid in the fire.
Ditch
on Maine. One start against a screwed up LA club does not a pitch
make.
Pitch or Ditch for Thursday, April 29
Burnett @ Matusz
Floyd @ Feldman – Floyd
was better against Seattle before tiring late, still
bullish
Duchscherer @
Romero
Pavano @
Willis
Hochevar @
Garza
Arroyo @
Oswalt
Kennedy @ Lilly
-
Both shamed my conservatism last time out!
D. Davis @
LeBlanc
Jurrjens @
Wainwright
Burres @
Kershaw
SIANO’S PICKS
Burnett @ Matusz Could be a duel or a softball
game.
Floyd @ Feldman Floyd has been too terrible I’m gonna sit this one out
even though I said pitch on Peavy in same series.
Duchscherer @
Romero
Pavano @ Willis fine I’ll pitch him.
Hochevar @
Garza
Arroyo @
Oswalt
Kennedy @ Lilly See Yankees vs. O’s. Lilly coming off triumphant return.
Kennedy coming off shutting down PHI.
D. Davis @
LeBlanc 11 innings and only one run and at home.
Brewers can rake but this may be worth a shot.
Jurrjens @
Wainwright
Burres @
Kershaw
Pitch or Ditch for Wednesday, April 28
Baker @
Scherzer
Westbrook @ Big
Erv – With Big Erv, it’s all about the matchups
Sabathia @
Guthrie
Lester @ Cecil – I like
Cecil but not vs. the Red Sox
Braden @
Shields – Braden may make a believer out of me if he handles the
Rays
Rowland-Smith @
Meche
Peavy @
Harden – Both with a lot to
prove
Maholm @ Narveson -
Narveson worth watching in NL-only leagues
Haeger @
Maine
Atilano @
Dempster
Benson @ G. Smith -
If there was ever a formula for a 14-12 game this is it
Hamels @
Lincecum – Matchup of the
night!
Leake @
Paulino
Correia @
Robertson – I’m willing to
gamble on both in this matchup
Kawakami @ Garcia
- Amazing that the Braves are a PoD target
***Siano agrees with everything except he says ditch Harden: “I only have a tad more confidence in Peavy than I do in Harden.”
Pitch or Ditch for Tuesday, April 27
Hughes @
Millwood
Liriano @ Verlander – Scuffling
Verlander not an automatic right now vs. hot Twins
Buchholz @ Marcum -
Marcum starting to prove himself
Sheets @ W. Davis
Buehrle @
Wilson
Snell @ Greinke
- So much for Snell as a sleeper; he goes to bullpen when Lee
returns
Talbot @ Saunders
TBD @ J. Santana – Padilla goes
to DL, Dodgers rotation gets thinner
Garland @ A. Sanchez
Harang @
Norris - Norris 17 K’s in 12.2 IP
and Reds are erratic
L. Hernandez @
Gorzelanny
TBD @ Wolf -
McCutchen sent down, Pirates rotation is just awful
Lowe @ Carpenter
Jackson @
Jimenez
Moyer @ Wellemeyer
Pitch or Ditch for Saturday-Monday, April 24-26
SATURDAY
Fister
@
F. Garcia
Pettitte @
Pineiro
Romero @
Niemann
Matusz @
Lackey
Blackburn @
Hochevar
Carmona @
Anderson
Willis @
Harden
LeBlanc @
Arroyo
Jurrjens @ Niese *Jair’s ERA misleading since it was the thumping in SD. Only Astros have a lower BA then Bravos in NL.
TBD @
Wandy
Lilly @ D. Davis *Piniella says pitch on teddy ballgame I
don’t
Robertson @
Cook
Kershaw @
Stammen
Figueroa @ Kennedy *Gonna pass on both. Kennedy not a
graduate.
Wainwright @
Zito *Nice test for Zito but at home and the way he
is going it’s a no brainer.
SUNDAY
J. Vargas @
Danks *Vargas an OK in AL-only play.
Morrow @
Price *Morrow needs to do it again but on
radar.
Slowey @
Bannister
Porcello @ Lewis *Porcello risky here but I’ll stick with him for
now.
Vazquez @
Kazmir
D. Hernandez @
Matsuzaka *Not yet on
Dice.
Masterson @ G.
Gonzalez *This has potential for a duel or a
softball game, I’ll guess duel.
Morton @
Myers
Billingsley @ Olsen *Wow Chad’s been bad but I think you need to trot him
out.
Wells
@
Bush
Penny @
Cain
Kendrick @ Lopez *Kendrick needs to do it again.
Volstad @ De La
Rosa
Richard @ Bailey *Hate when SD pitchers go on road but I like Richard.
His one road start was in COL and he did well.
Hanson @ Pelfrey *They swap bodies last
starts?
MONDAY
Beckett @ Eveland *I think Beckett is overrated but he’s a start. Enh on
Eveland.
Bonderman @
Harrison
King
Felix @
Davies
Huff @
Weaver
Kuroda @ O. Perez
Latos @ Johnson *Latos coming off a sick
start.
Lannan @ Silva *Triple dog dare ya
Duke @
Gallardo
Hudson @
Lohse
Haren @ Hammel *Danny boy needs to get going. Tough spot but roll him
out.
Halladay @ J.
Sanchez *I feel like this game is being played just
for me.
***For Saturday, Cory says “Pitch on Harden, maybe out of blind loyalty at this point? Detroit is
not so scary that I can’t give him another shot. Also ditch Niese, I don’t think
one decent start against the awful Cubs gets you in there just yet.”
***For Sunday, “Pitch Myers vs. the Pirates, and Dice-K vs. the O’s, based strictly on how
terrible those offenses are right now.”
Pitch or Ditch for Friday, April 23
Scherzer @
Feldman
Cecil @ Garza
Pavano @ Meche *I’m so happy I can jump right off Pavano train. You
know what some guys are just not consistent enough for me and you can disagree
with me it’s all good people.
Rowland-Smith @ Floyd *Both lineups are questionable right now so go for
it.
Westbrook @
Duchscherer *Duch strictly POD for me but this
is a good matchup unless bats wake up.
Guthrie @
Lester *I like Guthrie just not
here
Burnett @ E.
Santana *Big Erv with a big
test
Correia @ Cueto *Reds middle of the pack offense, Correia middle of the
pack SP. I’ll pass but feel free to gamble.
Kawakami @
Maine
Maholm @
Oswalt
Dempster @
Suppan
Nolasco @ G.
Smith
Hamels @
Benson
Haeger @
Marquis
Garcia @
Lincecum *0.69 and 0.90
ERAs
CORY’S PICKS
Scherzer @ Feldman
Cecil @ Garza
Pavano @ Meche – I think Pavano bounces
back vs. so-so Royals offense
Rowland-Smith @ Floyd – Mariners just the antidote to
Floyd’s early struggles
Westbrook @ Duchscherer – Not a big Duch fan, but
Tribe don’t score
Guthrie @ Lester
Burnett @ E.Santana – Can you blame me for
not trusting Big Erv?
Correia @
Cueto
Kawakami @ Maine
Maholm @ Oswalt
Dempster @ Suppan
Nolasco @ G.Smith – Coors is scary for
HR-prone Nolasco, but I’m riding the horse
Hamels @ Benson
Haeger @
Marquis
Garcia @ Lincecum – Tough matchup for Garcia but
results are impressive so far
.
Pitch or Ditch for Thursday, April 22
Wilson @
Buchholz
Sabathia @
Braden
Shields @
Peavy
Talbot @
Baker
Verlander @
Saunders
Gorzelanny @ J.
Santana
Jimenez @ L. Hernandez – Hard to take Livan seriously despite the 0.00 ERA
Padilla @ Leake – Could be 1-0, could be 12-9… I’m staying away
Moyer @ Lowe – Lowe
too erratic to trust vs. an elite offense
Wolf @ McCutchen – Wolf
should be solid against lower-tier offenses
An.
Sanchez @ Paulino – Sanchez
OK his first time, awful the last time… let’s see if Houston can get him
better
***Siano says “I agree with everything Cory said except I’m ditching Saundo. His two stinkers have been at home. If he pitches well here I’ll be more inclined
next go round.”
Pitch or Ditch for Tuesday, April 20
![]()
***Mike and Cory agree on these 100%. Here are the picks with Siano’s comments:
Davies @ Eveland *Playing the hot
hand
Lewis @ Wakefield *Patient teams will hurt Rangers
pitching. Wakefield probably on his way to pen.
Masterson @ Slowey
Price @ Danks
Porcello @ Kazmir *Kazmir in the Harden and Sheets
club right now. I’m passing.
Vazquez @ G. Gonzalez *You can hear some faint
music in the background for Javy. Brett Myers knows all about it.
D. Hernandez @ J. Vargas *Ditch these are AL-only plays at
best
De La Rosa @ Olsen *Bad job last time but I’m going
back in.
Bush @ Morton
Zambrano @ Pelfrey *Pelfrey win/save/win?? His
confidence has to be sky high.
Billingsley @ Bailey *Homer has been hittable and
Dodgers are hitting homers left and right in the middle of
order.
Kendrick @ Hanson *Kendrick DTM as of
now.
Volstad @ Myers *No K’s from Volstad but can be
effective.
Lohse @ Haren
J. Sanchez @ Latos *Sanchez coming off a
gem, thinking he keeps it up. I’m on the fence on Latos so just gonna pass until
he puts a few together. Low walks so one good sign.
Pitch or Ditch for Saturday-Monday, April 17-19
**MLB.com Fantasy 411 lands on MLB Network for 2010**
SATURDAY
Wilson @ Burnett – Wilson is coming off an illness
but the Yankees might make him sick
Saunders @ Tallet
Meche @ Blackburn
Guthrie @ Duchscherer – Last start
was much better, he’s at home and the O’s are scuffling
Peavy @ Westbrook - Not loving Peavy but the Indians can’t score
right now
Shields @ Buchholz
Verlander @ Rowland-Smith
Oswalt @
Gorzelanny - Poor,
poor Roy Oswalt!
Wolf @ L. Hernandez
J.
Santana @
Garcia
Lincecum @ Haeger - Haeger dominated the Fish last time,
but the Giants are actually scoring some runs these days so I’ll
pass
Cueto @ Ohlendorf
Nolasco @ Moyer
Jimenez @ Kawakami
TBD @ Correia
SUNDAY
Harden @ Pettitte
Floyd @ Carmona – Carmona is an enigma right
now, I’m waiting for a more clear direction
Big Erv @ Romero - Hard to trust Erv right now
Garza @
Lester -
AL Cy vs. the
runner-up
Hochevar @ Pavano – Still not trusting
Hochevar
Matusz @ Anderson - Undercard to Garza/Lester
Scherzer @ Snell
G. Smith @ Jurrjens - Have to believe Jurrjens will rebound at home vs.
the banged-up Rockies
D. Davis @ Marquis
Robertson @ Hamels
Arroyo @ Maholm
Wandy @
Dempster - Is Wandy hurt? I'll give
him one more start to find out
Kennedy @ TBD – If Kennedy
gives up 3 more HR in San
Diego I’m going to lose faith!
Zito @
Kershaw
Maine @ Wainwright
MONDAY
Niemann @ Lackey
Bannister @ Morrow
Willis @ Pineiro - Pineiro was sharp vs. the Yankees so
I’ll ride him at home vs. DET
Bergesen @
Fister
Wells @ Niese
Cook @ Stammen
Penny @ R. Lopez
Cain @
Richard - Richard
started well last time but faded, but I like him at home
SIANO’S PICKS
SATURDAY
Wilson
@ Burnett
Saunders
@ Tallet *Jays are hot
Meche
@ Blackburn
Guthrie @ Duchscherer *Guthrie hasn’t been bad.
Peavy @ Westbrook *Not surprised Peavy
is struggling but you can’t give up this early.
Shields @ Buchholz
Verlander @ Rowland-Smith *no-no alert
*RRS
2 k’s so far this year ummm pass.
Oswalt @ Gorzelanny *Last start vs Philly was stellar so
you have to trot him out, Gorz super last start too.
Wolf @ L. Hernandez *Wolf risky but good shot at Ks and W.
J. Santana @ Garcia *Still Johan. Mets
start proving they can hit out of Coors I’ll start fearing them.
Lincecum @ Haeger *I know 12 ks but really?
Cueto
@ Ohlendorf
Nolasco @ Moyer
Jimenez @ Kawakami
TBD
@ Correia
SUNDAY
Harden
@ Pettitte
Floyd @ Carmona
Big Erv @ Romero *A Siano delight. Yes Big Erv is
testing my patience. Feel free to tell me I’m crazy.
Garza @ Lester *Wow
Hochevar
@ Pavano
Matusz @ Anderson *A’s can’t hit, Anderson cooking
Scherzer @ Snell *Duel or ugly proceed with caution on
Snell.
G.
Smith @ Jurrjens *Jurrjens worth trotting him out.
D.
Davis @ Marquis
Robertson
@ Hamels
Arroyo @ Maholm
Wandy @ Dempster
Kennedy @ TBD *Kennedy has the stuff to succeed in NL and this is
SD.
Zito @ Kershaw
Maine
@ Wainwright
MONDAY
Niemann
@ Lackey *Niemann bounced back well from liner but that was Baltimore. He
does well here I may be buying.
Bannister @ Morrow *Bannister pitching well
Willis @ Pineiro *Once more before off d-train in mixed.
Feel free to ignore.
Bergesen
@ Fister
Wells @ Niese
Cook
@ Stammen
Penny @ R. Lopez
Cain @ Richard
Pitch or Ditch for Friday, April 16
**MLB.com Fantasy 411 lands on MLB Network for 2010**
Weaver @ Marcum
Harrison @
Sabathia
W. Davis @
Beckett
Greinke @
Baker
Millwood @
Braden – the way the O’s are going, I’ll keep going w/
Braden
Buehrle @
Talbot
Bonderman @ King
Felix - Bonderman was good
his first time out and the M’s are terrible
Anibal Sanchez @ Halladay – I like Anibal as a gamble this year but not in
Philly
Leake @
Duke
Gallardo @ Lannan
Hammel @
Lowe
Ol. Perez @
Carpenter
Jackson @
Garland
Paulino @ Silva – Well, I’ll start ALMOST everyone against the Astros
Wellemeyer @
Padilla
SIANO’S PICKS
Weaver @ Marcum
Harrison @
Sabathia
W. Davis @ Beckett
*I say ditch on Wade Davis…was not good last start at home vs Yanks and now
in Boston
Greinke @
Baker
Millwood @ Braden
Buehrle @ Talbot – A boringly
awesome performance coming from Buehrle
Bonderman @ King
Felix - Picking on those
M’s
Anibal Sanchez @ Halladay
Leake @ Duke
-
Gallardo @ Lannan
Hammel @ Lowe
Ol. Perez @
Carpenter
Jackson @
Garland
Paulino @ Silva
Wellemeyer @
Padilla
***DISAGREEMENTS: Cory says yes on Wade Davis, Siano’s rolling the dice on Millwood.

Recent Comments