411 Mock Draft Results + Analysis

Hey everyone,

Our five-round, 15-team mini-mock is in the books. 75 picks over e-mail took six days, which isn’t bad considering the snail-like pace of most e-mail drafts. You’ll probably recognize the names of all of the participants and I’d like to thank them for providing commentary to go along with their selection. Here’s the pick-by-pick analysis, and as always feel free to share your thoughts in the comments section.

I’ll gather this same group sometime in December or January for a full 23-rounder.


                                                                                                                                                  ROUND 1

# 1 : Fred Zinkie — Miguel Cabrera, 3B, DET

Easiest pick in the draft. I love Trout, but I can’t pass up filling my 3B spot and getting the most consistent hitter in baseball.

# 2 : Cory Schwartz – Mike Trout, OF, LAA

I was expecting Fred to take Trout #1 so of course I’ll take him here. He’s the five-category gold standard: a 30-30 threat who should compete for the league lead in steals and runs, and challenge for the batting title each season for the foreseeable future. With a full season in the #3 spot, he should coast past 100 RBI’s, too.

# 3 : David Gonos — Andrew McCutchen, OF, PIT

With Cabrera and Trout gone, the second tier is a little wider – and full of arguments on why I must be an absolute idiot to think this player is two spots higher than this player. (I love fantasy sports!) But I like McCutchen here for a few reasons.

-“Cutch” is my favorite nickname, and I’ve asked my loved ones to refer to me as such from now on.

-Cutch is one of just seven hitters to reach the 20-20 club in 2013.

-He stays healthy and has played over 150 games in each of the past four years, despite being a player heavy on the torso torque (also the name of my new death metal band) and speed on the basepaths.

-He turned 27 years old last week, and we get to hear E-Mack say, “Hayyyy, guess how old he is this season!?!!?! Twenty seven!!!”

-With the third pick, you want someone you can rely on and not worry about all season. “Cutch” is that man.

# 4 : Paul Sporer — Paul Goldschmidt, 1B, ARI

This is one of those situations where the player maybe “should” (insofar as anyone should go in a certain spot) go a few spots lower, but this is my only chance at him and I absolutely consider him an upper-first rounder. His power numbers stand alone at 36-125-103, but adding a .302 AVG and 15 SBs into the mix makes him just a phenomenal player. The SBs may continue to trickle downward (18 in 2012), but the power may have room to grow.

# 5 : Jason Collette — Carlos Gomez, OF, MIL

He’s Mike Trout ultra-light.

# 6 : Eric Mack — Chris Davis, 1B, BAL

# 7 : Lawr Michaels — Robinson Cano, 2B, FA

Kind of surprised he fell this far, and, not too concerned that he might switch uniforms. As in .314-27-107 at age 30?  I suspect he is one of those guys who could come out of a coffin and go 2-for-3 with a double and a run after being undead for a few centuries.

MLB: Miami Marlins at Washington Nationals

# 8 : Joe Sheehan — Bryce Harper, OF, WAS

Every reasonable position-player choice here is an injury case to one extent or another, and all pitchers are injury cases whether we know it yet or not. I can make arguments for four or five players. (I’ll spare names because of future picks, as I expect all to be gone before 2.7.) I’ll take a small reach based on age and upside.

# 9 : Jeff Erickson — Carlos Gonzalez, OF, COL

Like Joe suggested, so many options here. If we were going purely on $ value, I’d go with a particular pitcher, but my teams that start with a SP almost uniformly stink. So instead I’ll go with a guy that’s been worthless the last two Septembers, yet has still gone .300/20/20 both of those seasons. One of these years he’ll play 150 games and we’ll have a good laugh. Crossing my fingers that he’ll be able to squeeze his fingers in 2014.

# 10 : Zach Steinhorn — Hanley Ramirez, SS, LAD

Yeah, there’s some injury risk here, but Hanley is an elite five-category producer at a thin position who is still just 29. Project his 2013 stats over a full season and we’re talking video game numbers: 38 HR, 107 RBI, 117 R, 19 SB. If he comes anywhere remotely close to those, he will be well worth this pick.

# 11 : Tim Heaney — Adam Jones, OF, BAL

His low walk rate bugs me, and he’s not an entrenched 20-steal guy, but he can improve both. He’s just 28 years old. Even if he’s reached his peak (I don’t think he’s maxed out just yet), his power and established accompanying stats elevate him above the fringe first-round options here.

# 12 : Todd Zola – Jacoby Ellsbury, OF, FA

Sure, he’s an injury risk, but we’re talking about a 35% success rate of drafting a player in the first round and having him finish the season with first round value. Four of six seasons Ellsbury has been worthy of this pick – the other two he’s been hurt. I’ll take my chances that he plays enough to warrant this pick. If you’re reticent to lock down steals early because they’ll be available later, check out the paucity of pilfers this season – steals way down.

# 13 : Nando DiFino — Albert Pujols, 1B, LAA

A rested, repaired, motivated Pujols — with a very solid lineup surrounding him — could be a scary thing in 2014. I don’t think there’s a slam dunk pick here, so taking a risk on someone who was so good for so long and has a valid reason (I doubt he played a game without pain in 2013) for a sudden downturn in his stats works at this point in the draft.

# 14 : Nick Minnix — Edwin Encarnacion, 1B, TOR

Do 10 GP equal 3B eligibility again? I’ll take him, even if not, because 35-homer, 100-RBI players have become a little rarer. Otherwise, I might get stuck with someone like Pujols later.

# 15 : Derek VanRiper — Clayton Kershaw, SP, LAD

                                                                                                                                                  ROUND 2

# 1 : Derek VanRiper — Ryan Braun, OF, MIL

# 2 : Nick Minnix — Jason Kipnis, 2B, CLE

I can’t pull the trigger on Alex Rios just yet, so I’ll let Todd have him. I don’t think that there are too many concerns about Kipnis, who’s the most appealing middle infielder left, to me, for the 15-plus homers and 25-plus steals. Those marks go up if he doesn’t tank it in the second half this time around.

# 3 : Nando DiFino — Ian Desmond, SS, WAS

I flip-flopped between Tulowitzki and Desmond here, but decided to go with the 25/25 threat over the 30/2 threat. Desmond is also a better bet to stay healthy, and Washington isn’t afraid to bolster the lineup with some FA signings.

# 4 : Todd Zola — Prince Fielder, 1B, DET

A nice complement to Ellsbury both in terms of stats and reliability, Prince has missed one game the previous five seasons, including three 162-game campaigns in a row. I don’t see 2013 as the beginning of the slide, but rather a season at the low end of plausible outcomes. .300-30-100 is still a reasonable expectation.

# 5 : Tim Heaney — Alex Rios, OF, TEX

I’m buying the consolidation of Alex Rios’ skills, even if his swipes level off next year. He enjoyed hitting in Arlington — who doesn’t? — and, as has been noted by several participants in this draft at one point, he’s shedding the every-other-year label, thanks to alterations of both his mechanics and psyche. His age doesn’t scare me yet. I considered Jacoby Ellsbury last round but passed knowing I likely could nab a more balanced line in the second stanza from someone who puts the ball in play nearly as often. In Jones and Rios, I’ve pieced together two power-speed threats at the most insurable offensive position.

# 6 : Zach Steinhorn — Adrian Beltre, 3B, TEX

Beltre has reached the 30 HR mark in each of his three seasons with the Rangers and is coming off back-to-back .300 AVG campaigns. Age is my only concern but he’s showing no signs of slowing down and will continue to benefit from a friendly hitting environment in Texas.

# 7 : Jeff Erickson — Troy Tulowitzki, SS, COL

I debated between two players, neither of whom really run, which I don’t like. But given that I considered Tulo with my first-round pick, I’ll be riding the Rockies in this draft. Please, no fire sale with CarGo.

# 8 : Joe Sheehan — Giancarlo Stanton, OF, MIA

As a positional value honk, I don’t like taking outfielders early to the exclusion of players at other positions. When it looked like Tulo was getting to me, I was pretty happy. With him gone, I’ll take another strapping young power hitter who, if nothing else, locks down a ton of HR and RBI for me early. As with Harper, I suspect the injury-laden 2013 is making him seem more a ’14 risk than he is.

# 9 : Lawr Michaels — Buster Posey, C, SF

I had wanted to gamble on both Tulo and Giancarlo here. So much for the best laid plans. So, I’ll go in the direction of stats/position scarcity (though I don’t really believe in it) and take the guy who helped Z and I in the FSTA league. As Nate said (though I am paraphrasing) after LABR, “stats are stats, and it really does not matter where they come from.” Buster does produce stats. I will take them.

# 10 : Eric Mack — Justin Verlander, SP, DET

I hate being the guy that has to take a pitcher in roto.

# 11 : Jason Collette — Evan Longoria, 3B, TB

Homah, get your homah here. If they could only get a better leadoff hitter on in front of him.

# 12 : Paul Sporer — Joey Votto, 1B, CIN

Yep, two first basemen. Votto deserved a better fate, but an MLB-worst .281 OBP out of the #2 hole depressed his RBI. And yet he was still a top-25 hitter. This seems like taking Tim Duncan in fantasy basketball a few years ago (or hell, even now… he’s still awesome) where it’s just guaranteed production from an obvious star, but it doesn’t wow anyone like a Stanton or Longo pick (the two guys I hoped would fall).

# 13 : David Gonos — David Wright, 3B, NYM

Coming off a great (though injury-abbreviated) season, working out of a very thin position. And at 31, he still has plenty of years ahead of continued power. Had he stayed healthy in 2013, he would have been a candidate for a 25-25 season. I won’t be greedy, though. I’ll just take a 24-24 season from my third baseman.

MLB: NLCS-St. Louis Cardinals at Los Angeles Dodgers

# 14 : Cory Schwartz – Yasiel Puig, OF, LAD

Wow, just when I thought an erstwhile first-round caliber player was going to fall to me, they all just flew off the board one right after the other.

So, in a repeat of my 2nd round pick from last year’s exercise, in which I sparked considerable debate by taking a cocky 20-year-old who made the jump from Double-A to the Majors and posted very-good-but-not-great numbers while still earning universal praise for his overall game and immediate potential, I’ll take Yasiel Puig. Like Bryce Harper before him, Puig has major power upside, can steal some bags, and while his plate discipline is certainly weaker than Harper’s, he still managed to hit .319 this year (side note: given the ongoing offensive trends of the last few years, I am placing greater emphasis on the Triple Crown categories in the earlier rounds, over speed and/or positional scarcity, more than ever). To be fair, Harper didn’t justify a 1st round pick this season, but given that Joe just took him 8th overall — 8 picks earlier than I did last year, despite his disappointing season — I don’t feel too bad about this one.

Prediction: Fred takes Starling Marte with one of his next two picks.

# 15 : Fred Zinkie — Jose Bautista, OF, TOR

I’m pretty sure Cory is using reverse psychology on me with Marte. Or maybe it’s double reverse psychology! Well, it’s not going to work! Unless, of course your goal was for me to not take Marte. In which case it did!

I’ll take Bautista, even though it worries me that he hasn’t finished either of the past two seasons. He’s similar to CarGo, in that he can be a first-round value if he plays 155 games. He still has 40-homer potential.

                                                                                                                                                  ROUND 3

# 1 : Fred Zinkie — Yu Darvish, SP, TEX

277 K’s is a lot. If he didn’t miss that start before the ASB he would have been around 285. I felt like grabbing an elite SP, and there are so many good ones. Darvish’s K’s made him stand out to me. The Astros are staying in the AL West, right?!

# 2 : Cory Schwartz – Freddie Freeman, 1B, ATL

Most of the players I like on the board right now are outfielders (Marte, Bruce, Pence, Werth, J-Up, Heyward), but I already have two of those. I’d like to get a middle infielder like Pedroia, but can’t give up that much power this early. So, I’m going to reach a little and take Freeman. I don’t think he’s really a .319 hitter, since his BABIP was ridiculously high this year, but I do expect .290-.300 with continued power growth and strong RBI numbers.

# 3 : David Gonos — Dustin Pedroia, 2B, BOS

# 4 : Paul Sporer — Jay Bruce, OF, CIN

Bruce is averaging 32-102-87-.257 the last three years with lows of 30-97-84-.252, which shows his incredible consistency. His teammate being on my team affords me the ability to take the batting average hit.

# 5 : Jason Collette —  Matt Hollliday, OF, STL

There are a few guys I really like here, but Holliday’s incredible consistency is tough to pass on.

# 6 : Eric Mack — Jean Segura, SS, MIL

Everyone hates him for his second half, but I hate drafting steals or shortstops.

# 7 : Lawr Michaels — Matt Kemp, OF, LAD

Not sure I understand why Tulo and Cargo are worth the risk, but suddenly everyone is afraid of Kemp, but I am not.

Before 2012, he did not play in less than 150 games, and he is still 29 (meaning I was three years older than he is now when he was born, which is really scary). Due for some solid health, and probably a more stable team behind him for a full year. But, if Hanley never dropped below a third rounder during his struggles, well…

# 8 : Joe Sheehan — Jose Reyes, SS, TOR

Combining the injury risk of Kemp with the speed and position of Segura adds up to my pick at 3.8. He’ll steal his age, more or less, and the runs scored upside if that whole lineup is working is huge. He’s always a health risk. This pick blends nicely with the two young power-hitting outfielders — I did not want a third OF here.

# 9 : Jeff Erickson — Allen Craig, 1B, STL

I thought about taking a SP here, but I’m going to hold out for at least one more round, and instead take one of the remaining “first basemen I’d take before Pujols” – that category is starting to dwindle.

The power dropped off this year, but I think it can come back, and I’m convinced that the batting average is rock-solid.

# 10 : Zach Steinhorn — Justin Upton, OF, ATL

Can’t go another round without taking an OF, so let’s just hope that this guy finally has the type of season I thought he’d have in 2012. And then in 2013. One of these years I’ll be right. Maybe.

# 11 : Tim Heaney — Shin-Soo Choo, OF, FA but hoping CIN

The CI lot … carbon copies of tepid or flawed players. I’m not ready to take a SP yet. I thought about taking my brother in Paleo, but man, despite how spritely I’ve run for the last 1.5 years, I’m not sure if Hunter Pence can swipe 22 bags again.

Alas, someone around his age that has rattled off 20-plus thefts and 16-plus homers in each of his last four full seasons is Shin-Soo Choo. I’m aware that wherever he signs may sway the runs or homers column, but fun fact: 11 of Choo’s 21 taters this past year came when he wasn’t playing in GABP. (I also now have 3 outfielders through 3 rounds. Times have changed).

# 12 : Todd Zola – Chris Sale, SP CHW

If there was a hitter I remotely favored over the others here I would take him and wait until round 4 for a SP since there are a bunch I still like as an anchor – but since there isn’t a hitter that I can distinguish from the rest I’ll take the SP I like the best and grab a bat in the 4th.

# 13 : Nando DiFino — Max Scherzer, SP, DET

Scherzer has improved in nearly every measurable category in each of his last three seasons. Even if he takes a minor step back to a happy place between 2012 and 2013, I’m still looking at some pretty sweet numbers across the board and a possible league lead in strikeouts.

MLB: Texas Rangers at Kansas City Royals

# 14 : Nick Minnix — Elvis Andrus, SS, TEX

Elvis Andrus was a top-30 fantasy hitter this season, as far as I can tell. Seems like he’s been around for a handful of years — perhaps without impressing you — because he has been. Yet 2014 will be just his age-25 season, and there may be a 10- to 15-homer campaign, or at least a .400 slugging rate, hidden in there somewhere. But another year like this one will do juuust fine. That he’s a rock-solid shorty is the bonus, in my book. I’d take Reyes before him, but not Segura.

# 15 : Derek VanRiper — Adam Wainwright, SP, STL

                                                                                                                                                  ROUND 4

#1: Derek VanRiper — Jose Fernandez, SP, MIA

To hell with hitting (more on this between now and 3/31/14). I’m taking Adam Wainwright and Jose Fernandez. The extra innings Wainwright typically gives compared to other top-tier pitchers helps offset potential limitations for Fernandez next year, while I feel as though Fernandez has the ability to maintain elite ratios thanks to the benefit of a very pitcher-friendly home park run environment on top of a dominant arsenal.

#2: Nick Minnix — Yoenis Cespedes, OF, OAK

Sounds as if there’s a good chance that Cespedes is traded this winter. Just about any other destination would represent an upgrade in offensive environment. Doesn’t matter to me where he is, though, his power plays. I think health (or lack thereof, and less than perfect plate discipline) is all that has stood between him and a big-money season in the States. He’s in the category of a number of other players who’ve already gone, in that regard. Something like 35 homers and 15 or 20 steals, possibly? Hate to pass up a number of other outstanding and perceptibly reliable players here, but won’t skip Cespedes’ upside.

#3: Nando DiFino – Jedd Gyorko, 2B, SD

I’m not sure if this is one of those “where he should go” or “where he should finish” formats, but Jedd Gyorko hit 23 home runs in just 125 games as a rookie, in a park that is still pretty pitcher-friendly, in a lineup that didn’t offer him a lot of protection, and while probably playing 20 of those games with his groin injury still bothering him. Gyorko’s minor league numbers suggest his average will rise, and I wouldn’t be surprised if his power takes a nice jump, too. It took Robinson Cano five seasons to hit 20 homers; it took Gyorko one. I’m all for a second baseman with that kind of pop.

#4: Todd Zola – Mark Trumbo, 1B, LAA

Don’t love this pick but at this point of my preparation, I don’t have anyone that sticks out. 30 HR with 95 RBI pretty bankable and a .250 BA isn’t as detrimental as it was a couple years ago. Positional considerations are way overrated – I’ll find viable middlemen later – I’ll take the reliability with the outside shot of a mini-Chris Davis like spike in power.

#5: Tim Heaney – Ian Kinsler, 2B, TEX

Had Trumbo all lined up. Thanks, Todd.

Other corner infield options still bore me. There’s one other MI that intrigues me, but I’ll continue with my power-speed game. I don’t want to bank on such potential from middle and late-rounders. Though he took a stats dip and might be leaving Arlington, as long as Kinsler is wearing a Rangers uniform, I’ll value him here. Ask me again in March, though.

#6: Zach Steinhorn – Starling Marte, OF, PIT

I’m light in speed right now so I’ll go with this 25-year-old OF who is a safe bet for 35-plus steals, a strong AVG and plenty of runs hitting atop an up and coming lineup. I wouldn’t be surprised to see a power spike as well.

#7: Jeff Erickson – Everth Cabrera, SS, SD

I would have taken Marte had Zach let him go.

That said, there are still plenty of SP’s I like, and while a bunch of them will surely fly off before my next pick, I still feel good with who will be left in the 5th, if not even the 6th, or both.

Hopefully I’ve addressed BA with my first three picks, so for this one I wanted to tackle either HR or SBs. I decided to go with SBs, which may have a better chance of getting some help with BA too. He’s a risk given his return from suspension and ballpark. The funny thing is that I’m not a huge positional scarcity honk, yet I now have two SS’s.

MLB: Cincinnati Reds at Houston Astros#8: Joe Sheehan – Billy Hamilton, OF, CIN

So I guess this is where I go off the rails.

Billy Hamilton stole 13 bases in 13 games, 22 plate appearances. He was caught once, and that required a pretty perfect pitch, catch and throw.

As I see it, there are two ways that taking him here can be justified, and one in which it is not. One, he starts for the Reds, playing CF with a .300 OBP and at least 85 steals. I think as an everyday player, Vince Coleman’s 1986 or 1988 is about Hamilton’s 40th percentile projection — 80-100 steals, 80-100 runs. Two, Hamilton is the world’s greatest pinch-runner, not good enough to start but so valuable tactically that he stays on the roster all year. He stole 13 bases in that role in one month — that’s 78 in a full season, with 60 runs scored.

The downside is that he’s not good enough to be a regular, and the Reds decide to let him have a second year at Triple-A. It’s actually become unusual for good prospects to repeat Triple-A, so I’m betting that the trend continues. I’m passing up starting pitchers here, but I can find starting pitchers elsewhere. I can’t find 80 steals in one roster spot anywhere else.

Hamilton is nearly impossible to peg right now. I believe that if he looks at all like a regular on February 15, though, no one will get him at anything like 4.8 in March.

#9: Lawr Michaels – Madison Bumgarner, SP, SF

Boy, I am confused.

And, I suspect you guys are in the same boat. I will preface by saying that the reason I love mocks like this are because we do take chances (eg, Hamilton and Marte are chancy to me at this point). And I don’t mean that as a slight: as Cory will confirm and I figure you know, I never try to get too locked down into who to pick when for what. It is more a case of I understand I need to build a team and as long as I walk away with competitors, it doesn’t matter how or where I get my production as long as the pieces add up to solve the equation.

That said, I had four different picks in my head for this round (and the next, I suppose). Anyway, I am going with a pitcher since I really am not happy unless I have a foundation of something on my team. 24, killer year last year, great park, oddly seems to have inherited the #1 mantle from two extremely good arms. Plus at 25, I think he could really get better.

#10: Eric Mack – Jason Heyward, OF, ATL

I debated between him and Wil Myers. I’ll take the higher ceiling.

#11: Jason Collette – Josh Donaldson, 3B, OAK

I have an irrational love for this guy. I was a cheerleader for him last offseason and took him everywhere for $10 or less and watched him return a huge profit. His numbers have been incredibly consistent since being recalled from the Minors in August 2012.

#12: Paul Sporer – Domonic Brown, OF, PHI

Brown burst onto the scene with his hot May, but he stayed strong throughout the remainder of the year, too, with 12 HR, 47 RBI and a .272 AVG (not to mention a 9% BB rate) which yields about a 24-90 full season. I’ve always been a fan and I was banging the “change of scenery” drum pretty fiercely, but he overcame and had success with Philly. The skills could dip back a little and we might still see a bottom line improvement just by his staying healthier (139 GP).

#13: David Gonos – Yadier Molina, C, STL

Going against my normal drafting plans and taking a catcher early – mostly because I’m not crazy about what’s left. Molina will help with batting average and possibly power from a position that usually hurts those categories. He also has averaged over 490 at-bats over the past four seasons, which ranks among the top three at the position in that span. High batting average plus high at-bats equals me saying, “Hi, Yadier Molina!” … I need coffee.

#14: Cory Schwartz – Hunter Pence, OF, SF

Not sure I like having three outfielders in the first four rounds – OK, I definitely don’t – but in my opinion Hunter Pence is clearly the best player left on the board, so I’ll take him… by 2013 stats alone he was a borderline first-round value. But, I don’t feel like I’m buying a career year with this pick, as his AVG, OBP, walk and strikeout rates, SLG, ISO, etc., were all nearly dead-ringers for his career averages. The only outlier in his 2013 line is the stolen bases, but even with regression he should provide double-digits in that category, and I’m still more focused on power than speed right now anyway.

#15: Fred Zinkie – David Ortiz, DH, BOS

I was watching something called the World Series last night, and I noticed that this Ortiz guy is pretty good. He was terrific this year after missing the first couple weeks of the season. His skills could fall off quickly at any time. But there don’t seem to be many signs of that happening right away. Great talent, great supporting cast — I’ll live with having my utility spot tied up.

                                                                                                                                                  ROUND 5

#1: Fred Zinkie – Craig Kimbrel, RP, ATL

I’m fine with taking a closer early, and Kimbrel is certainly deserving of the spot. He is as talented and consistent as any player.

Kimbrel and Ortiz were both in the top-20 in the ESPN player rater last season. They could both drop off a bit and still be worth picks 60 and 61.

#2: Cory Schwartz – Ryan Zimmerman, 3B, WAS

A few ways I could go here… Matt Carpenter, Ryan Zimmerman or Jonathan Lucroy to start filling in some positional needs, Kenley Jansen or Aroldis Chapman to make sure I get an elite CL now that Fred has popped the seal on that need, or another “best available” OF like Alex Gordon. I guess I’ll take Zimmerman, who seems to be the least likely of this bunch to be around at my next pick, or is at least the one with the least obvious comp of who might be around 26 picks from now. Zimmerman seems to have overcome his shoulder issues (at least from an offensive standpoint) and is a solid five-category contributor at a position that doesn’t have many of those. He’s still in his (late) prime, and the Nationals’ offense should be stronger next year, so there’s still time for him to put up a career year, although something like the last two years’ production would be perfectly fine too.

#3: David Gonos – Wil Myers, OF, TB

Just to prove I’m not homer-phobic, I’ll take Myers here. Produces across the board, and as long as the BoSox fans didn’t screw up his psyche too bad, should be an RBI machine next to Longo for years to come.

#4: Paul Sporer – Matt Carpenter, 2B, STL

I wasn’t sure Carpenter would make it back to me. I was on board with the preseason love for Carp, but unfortunately I saw him going into that “such a sleeper, he’s now overrated” bin that I didn’t get him in too many leagues. My loss. He exceeded even the wildest expectations with a huge season atop a potent lineup. His runs will likely drop as I doubt STL hits .912 w/RISP again, but I’ll take .280-100-10-65 as a floor.

#5: Jason Collette – Daniel Murphy, 2B, NYM

Go on, steal my pick, it’s your birthday. Plan B for me as I go for the rare undervalued player in New York.

#6: Eric Mack – Stephen Strasburg, SP, WAS

#7: Lawr Michaels – Leonys Martin, OF, TEX

Hmm. Well, I had both Donaldson (as noted) and Carpenter on my “I’m confused” list. I would have probably gone Carpenter here due to position flex, had Paul not beat me to the punch.

So, I will go with the last guy on my list (for now).

I am kind of surprised he lasted this long, by the way, in deference to the general love for Marte. But, that guy is Leonys Martin, whose numbers across the board are in line with Marte, but who is on a better hitting team, in a better home yard for hitters.

#8: Joe Sheehan – David Price, SP, TB

I knew taking Hamilton that I’d be taking the best available starting pitcher here. I didn’t know it would be such a tough call. I am sure, however, that this pitcher is a better pick than some of the starters already taken, his 2014 ranking depressed by two lost months at the start of 2013 — ineffectiveness and injury that I do not think will have much bearing on his 2014 performance. I think I’m getting the guy with the 102/13 K/BB.

#9: Jeff Erickson – Cliff Lee, SP, PHI

While the team context is bad, it’s hard to hate on getting Cliff Lee in the fifth round. I know I’m getting good ratios and Ks; I’ll cross my fingers and hope he gets 13-15 wins. Also considered King Felix and a couple of hitters here.

#10: Zach Steinhorn – Felix Hernandez, SP, SEA

And I’ll go with King Felix. I rarely draft starting pitching this early but I think there’s a good chance at least one of the hitters I have in mind (A-Gon, Hosmer, Carlos Santana, among others) would still be around by the time I’d make my next pick and consider Felix at #70 to be pretty solid value.

#11: Tim Heaney – Pedro Alvarez, 3B, PIT

It’s approaching my wheelhouse for pitching, but not just yet. I’ll tolerate Alvarez’s plate-discipline flaws at Pick 71 because he arguably holds the best established power left. I would’ve taken Mark Trumbo last round had he been available. I’ll repeat that philosophy for someone with eligibility at a position with numerous intriguing fliers left but, in my opinion, drops off in tangible offerings after Alvarez. Expect 30ish homers. Pray to the cruel fantasy deities for a .250 BA. Celebrate anything above that. Time to build up BA in my subsequent picks!

#12: Todd Zola – Cole Hamels, SP, PHI

I realize that this is not an NFBC draft and sometimes I stray too NFBC centric, but when I see 15 teams, I tilt to that format and there you need to draft pitching earlier than most suggest. To that end, I’ll continue the 5th round theme of “what have you done for me lately” and take Cole Hamels. I find it interesting that perhaps only Zimmerman was ranked in this area code last season; everyone else was higher or lower. I realize that sounds like a “well duh” statement implying that I don’t realize the rankings of players change, it’s just my experience that there are usually a stable of typical “fifth round players” that are always taken around now. But not this year.

MLB: Tampa Bay Rays at Los Angeles Angels

#13: Nando DiFino – Josh Hamilton, OF, LAA

I’m going with Josh Hamilton. I figure he got his “play like crap under a large new contract” season out of the way, and he’ll spend the entire offseason focused and ready to prove 2013 was a fluke.

#14: Nick Minnix – Ben Zobrist, 2B, TB

Well, it’s kind of a boring pick, but I think it was just another one of those down years in the HR department for Zobrist, who puts up Alex Gordon’s numbers in a normal year but provides that ridiculous flexibility, too. I have a couple of speed providers already, or I might have thought harder about Michael Bourn, whose depressed SB number may be health-related more than anything else, because I don’t think his speed would decline so sharply and stay there for his age-31 season.

#15: Derek VanRiper – Adrian Gonzalez, 1B, LAD

Gonzalez was among the hitters considered when I opted to take a third pitcher to begin Round 4, and while the ceiling isn’t as high as it was during his power peak, the team context is excellent and the floor is such that I feel he’s a nice value in this spot. On the surface, Gonzo looks like a top-50 player again in 2014 — with the chance to hit in a lineup that gets something closer to 162 games from Hanley and Puig plus any potential free agent additions.

1 Comment

went Roy Halladay-King Felix 1 n 2 one year, 14 teamer…won pretty EZ

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: