W. Chen @ Kluber – Chen is a toss-up, but he’s much better at home than on the road and this matchup isn’t great.
Paxton @ Porcello – Paxton has been decent but I don’t like this matchup.
Keuchel @ Buchholz – Buchholz is DTM.
McCarthy @ Cobb
Richards @ Martinez
Stroman @ Noesi
Duffy @ Nolasco
Morton @ Roark – Morton has been a little erratic of late and the Nats offense is hot.
T. Wood @ Wheeler
Cahill @ Hand
Hammel @ A. Wood - Sticking with Hammel for now.
T. Ross @ Lynn
Cueto @ Morales
Nelson @ Greinke – Tough matchup for Nelson but he’s coming off four straight quality starts.
Hamels @ Bumgarner
Liriano @ Scherzer
Samardzija @ Shields
Feldman @ Webster
Odorizzi @ R. Ross
R. Hernandez @ Harang
Fiers @ Jackson – Fiers is a nice blue-plate special if you can afford to take a risk
Strasburg @ Gee – Gee’s been erratic; play it safe if your categories dictate
C. Anderson @ Penny
Stults @ Lackey – good matchup for Lackey to bounce back
Simon @ J. De La Rosa – Simon has been good enough to trust in Coors vs. depleted Rox
Gibson @ Oberholtzer
Pineda @ Tillman
Chafin @ Bauer (Gm 1) – Bauer hot and cold right now, but D-backs are cold with Goldy out.
Nuno @ Tomlin (Gm 2)
Worley @ Farmer
Archer @ Mikolas
Kazmir @ Vargas
Burnett @ Weaver – don’t like Burnett vs. Angels’ offense
Dickey @ Iwakuma
Ranaudo @ Leake
Quintana @ Peavy
Matzek @ Kennedy
Ryu @ Big Erv
Zimmermann @ Colon
Masterson @ Eovaldi
Lohse @ Wada
NYY @ BAL (PPD)
Collmenter @ House – Collmenter’s road/home splits are uuuugly
Hellickson @ Tepesch – not totally sold on Hellickson yet, but great matchup
Lester @ Guthrie
Pino @ McHugh – McHugh’s been consistently good this year
Williams @ Wilson
Happ @ Young
Ray @ Volquez
Haren @ Minor – high risk/high reward on both. Let the categories be your guide
Kelly @ Latos
Fister @ R. Montero
Wainwright @ Cosart
Peralta @ Hendricks – Hendricks may be O2W though
Flande @ Despaigne
Sale @ Vogelsong
***ZACH SAYS “I’d pass on Hellickson. I just don’t trust him yet and Rangers Ballpark is never an easy place to pitch. Agree on rest.”
Shelby Miller (@MIA, vs. SD)
Coming off a terrific rookie campaign, Miller has been an overall disappointment this season, so much so that he was temporarily bumped from the Cardinals rotation last month. But in three starts since rejoining the starting staff, he’s registered a 2.41 ERA and 0.59 WHIP. The Padres remain the lowest scoring team in the Majors by a healthy margin while the overachieving Marlins offense has fallen back down to earth of late, ranking 11th in the NL in runs scored since the All-Star break. If available on the wire, Miller is a must-add in all mixed leagues of 12 teams or more. Next week is as good a time as any to trot him out there.
Tom Koehler (vs. STL, vs. ARI)
Although Koehler’s dominant April (2.97 ERA) is a distant memory by now, he does have six quality starts in his last nine tries. His ERA at home is 2.45, this compared to a 5.05 mark away from Miami, and the Cardinals and Diamondbacks both rank in the bottom third of the NL in runs scored on the road. I’m convinced. Pitch.
Odrisamer Despaigne (vs. COL, @STL)
Being that he’s fresh off three straight mediocre performances, pitching Despaigne next week might seem like a leap of faith. Well, I’m ready to take that leap. Let’s not forget that through his first five big league starts, the Padres righty boasted a 1.31 ERA, so the talent is certainly there for him to finish the season strong. The Rockies are by far the highest scoring team in the Majors when at home, but it’s an entirely different story away from Coors Field, as they rank 28th in runs scored on the road. Meanwhile, the Cardinals offense has struggled all year. In shallower formats, maybe there are better waiver wire options, but even in a 12-team mixed, Despaigne would be squarely on my radar.
Drew Smyly (@TEX, vs. NYY)
In our Pitch or Ditch posts, we’ve had a love/hate relationship with Smyly all season, and quite honestly, I’m not as high on him as Cory might be. I do think he has a bright future, but is he an automatic start in 12-team mixed leagues? Far from it. And getting traded to the Rays doesn’t exactly help his outlook, as his run support will almost certainly take a hit. Smyly actually pitched very well at Rangers Ballpark back in June, but I still don’t trust him there. Starting him against the Yankees is something I’d probably do in a daily lineup league, but for the two-start week, I just don’t have a good feeling about this.
Dan Haren (@ATL, vs. MIL)
At this point, I’m so down on Haren that I wouldn’t even pitch him in a two-start week coming off a gem versus a tough Angels lineup. Why? Because that was only his second quality start in his last nine outings. The bottom line is that Haren is a shell of his former self, his stuff and velocity so diminished that he often looks like he’s throwing batting practice. The Brewers rank 2nd in the NL in both runs scored and homers, and while the Braves have been a sub-par offense this year, Haren sports an ugly 4.99 ERA through 13 road starts.
Mike Minor (vs. LAD, vs. OAK)
This one is kind of obvious, as Minor has been a mess this year while both of these opposing lineups are very dangerous. But from a big picture perspective, it goes to show just how unpredictable starting pitching can be from one year to the next. This is a guy who was an undisputed top-30 SP heading into the season. Four months later, he’s an automatic ditch in all mixed leagues, even in a two-start week. Go figure.
Kluber @ McCarthy – McCarthy since joining Yankees (5 starts): 4-0, 2.08 ERA.
Scherzer @ Stroman – Tough matchup for Stroman though, as he’s coming off worst outing in awhile.
Lackey @ Jimenez
Hudson @ Shields
Darvish @ Feldman
Buchholz @ Richards
TBD (MIN) @ Samardzija
Noesi @ Paxton – Keep an eye on Paxton but let’s see him shake off the rust first.
Odorizzi @ Jackson
Gee @ Hamels – Gee coming off solid bounce back performance.
Stults @ Liriano – Nice matchup for Liriano.
Greinke @ Fiers
Roark @ Harang – Harang pitching well enough to start here.
TBD (MIA) @ Simon – Simon fading a bit but I’m not ready to jump ship yet.
J. De La Rosa @ Cahill – De La Rosa a decent play in deeper leagues but I just don’t fully trust him.
Carrasco @ Kuroda
Price @ Buehrle – Regression was inevitable for Buehrle.
Lynn @ Gausman – Three straight quality starts for Gausman and Cards have been a bottom tier offense this year.
Lincecum @ Duffy – Lincecum erratic of late but I’ll stick with him for now.
Martinez @ Keuchel
R. De La Rosa @ Santiago – Taking the safe route here but both are worthy gambles in deeper leagues.
Hughes @ Hammel
Danks @ TBD (SEA)
Hand @ Cueto
Wheeler @ Kendrick – Kendrick pitching decently lately but Mets have roughed him up this year (6.23 ERA).
T. Ross @ Morton
Kershaw @ Nelson – Nelson’s on a roll.
Cobb @ T. Wood
Morales @ Miley – I’m back to not trusting Miley at home. 10 ER outing will do that.
G. Gonzalez @ A. Wood
Capuano @ Norris – Norris an intriguing AL-only option though.
Smyly @ Lewis – Playing it safe with Smyly in tough environment.
Gray @ Ventura
Milone @ Peacock
Hutchison @ King Felix
Niese @ Buchanan
Correia @ Teheran
Verlander @ Locke – Not a believer in Locke.
Miller @ Koehler – Giving Koehler another chance in favorable matchup.
Gallardo @ Arrieta
Lyles @ Hahn – Hahn very impressive this year and Rockies can’t hit on the road.
Masterson @ Tillman
Bauer @ Rogers
An. Sanchez @ Dickey – Dickey pitches better at home and Tigers are scuffling a little offensively
Bumgarner @ Vargas
Mikolas @ Oberholtzer
Webster @ Weaver
Gibson @ Kazmir
Quintana @ Iwakuma
Archer @ Wada
Colon @ Burnett
Kennedy @ Worley – might as well ride the Worley train
Eovaldi @ Leake – blue-plate special on both if your categories will allow the risk
Strasburg @ Big Erv
R. Hernandez @ Lohse
Matzek @ C. Anderson
***ZACH SAYS “I’d give Tillman a shot at home (2.78 ERA this year) against a non-elite offense. Agree on rest.”
Porcello @ Greene
M. Gonzalez @ Happ – I’m a fan of Gonzalez, but not here.
Ryu @ Wilson – Playing it safe with the struggling Wilson in not so ideal matchup.
Pino @ Lester
Carroll @ Elias – Elias 16 IP, 3 ER, 21 K over his last three starts.
deGrom @ Zimmermann
Peavy @ Peralta – Not overly confident in Peavy but I’ll go for it.
Hendricks @ Flande
McHugh @ O’Sullivan
Flynn @ Volquez
House @ Bailey
Workman @ Wainwright – Workman not a bad option in deeper leagues but I wouldn’t fully trust him in a 12-team mixed.
Guthrie @ Nuno
Despaigne @ Correia – Despaigne roughed up his last time out but deserves a shot here.
Tepesch @ Sale
Hellickson @ Gray
Teheran @ Young
Verlander @ Capuano – Verlander pitching well lately.
W. Chen @ Hutchison – Chen a decent option in deeper leagues but I’m not a fan of this matchup.
Haren @ Shoemaker – Bench Haren until further notice. Shoemaker a borderline call but I’ll play it safe in tough matchup.
Niese @ Fister
Peacock @ Buchanan
Koehler @ Locke – Koehler 3 ER or less in four straight starts. Locke scares me.
Salazar @ Latos
Kelly @ Miller – Shelby a bit risky though.
Vogelsong @ Gallardo
Arrieta @ Lyles
Ventura @ Collmenter – Collmenter a worthy NL-only play.
Cueto @ Tomlin
Price @ Kuroda – Kuroda has been a little better lately.
Norris @ Buehrle – Not trusting Buehrle here.
Lewis @ Danks
Hahn @ Hughes – Favorable matchup for both.
Smyly @ Hammel – Taking a break from Smyly in tough matchup, so expect a shutout!
A. Wood @ King Felix
Wheeler @ G. Gonzalez
Keuchel @ Kendrick
Hand @ Morton – Morton a little risky here, but he’s rarely terrible.
Lincecum @ Nelson – Lincecum’s last two starts concern me while Nelson has been solid over his last two.
R. De La Rosa @ Lynn – Rubby 3 ER or less in five of his last six outings.
T. Wood @ B. Anderson – Anderson has pitched pretty well this year but I’m scared to start him at Coors.
Duffy @ Miley – Miley has struggled at home but Royals offense is mediocre at best.
Santiago @ Kershaw – Santiago a sneaky play in deeper leagues though.